United States of EuropeUnited States of Europe
analysisTransatlantic relations

Without one voice, Europe remains a spectator in Shenzhen

As leaders from Washington, Beijing and Moscow meet in China to reshape global affairs, Europe's separate gathering in Berlin reveals the cost of fragmented foreign policy.

By United States of Europe editorial team · How we write editorial

US President Donald Trump, Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin appeared together for a group photograph in Shenzhen on 19 November ahead of a closely watched trilateral summit. As the three leaders met to negotiate global security and economic relations, no European representative was at the table.

The meeting in China has drawn comparisons to a new Yalta conference, raising concerns that major powers are preparing to redivide global influence without European input. In response, dozens of European heads of state and government gathered in Berlin to coordinate a reaction to the shift and plan a follow-up summit.

Sceptics of a integrated European foreign policy argue that individual capitals preserve national flexibility by managing their own diplomatic relations. Yet when three superpowers convene to set terms on international trade and security, 27 individual European voices carry little leverage on their own.

Scrambling to organize emergency counter-summits from the sidelines illustrates the limits of national fragmentation. If European nations want their stability and economic interests protected in a changing world, they must pool their diplomatic weight to ensure Europe helps shape the global order rather than merely reacting to it.

Sources

More from the editorial team